Reflections on Crime and Punishment
Summary of the Book
Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s Crime and Punishment takes place in St. Petersberg, Russia, during the 1860s. It centers around Raskolnikov, a man in his early 20s from a modest family who is helping fund his law school education in the hopes that he can become a government official. He has a history of being an upstanding citizen, once running into a burning building to save a child.
Raskolnikov has run out of money to pay for his education and basic living expenses. He has received funds by trading in his few possessions to a stingy pawnbroker, an old woman who everyone hates and who treats her handicapped niece like a slave. He learns that his sister is on the verge of marrying a rich but vile man so she can help her brother pay for school.
He decides that the best course of action would be to kill the pawnbroker and take her money, thus saving his sister from a miserable marriage, freeing the pawnbroker’s niece, and enabling him to finish school and become a benevolent bureaucrat.
After becoming physically ill and mentally exhausted from trying to cope with this decision, he drops out of school and ceases his tutoring jobs. He eventually carries out the act, also killing the niece who was a witness.
He spends months in a state of extreme paranoia and exhaustion. He lashes out at his sister, mother, and friends for no reason. He suspects the government knows what he did and is attempting to trick him into confessing. He wanders about the city, briefly considers suicide, and can’t even bring himself to use or account for the money and goods he stole.
He gives the last of the money his mother sent him to a stranger whose drunk husband had died. He develops a crush on the stranger’s daughter, Sonia, and eventually confides in her. To his surprise, this makes her fall in love with him, likely because she sees herself as sinful due to her prostitution.
Eventually, Raskolnikov goes to the police station and confesses his crime. He is sent to a prison labor camp in Siberia, and Sonia goes with him. Sonia is a devout Christian who prays for him and brings him a Bible to read. Being in prison gives him time and space to reflect on what he has done, while simultaneously not feeling guilty.
He does not regret the murder he committed. To the contrary, he deeply resents himself for not being the “higher man” he thought he was-- the type of man who could forge his own morality and act accordingly, unbothered by the moral systems of lesser men (a la Nietzsche’s Ubermensch).
In the last couple pages of the novel, Raskolnikov appears to be turning toward a new and conventionally better path-- falling in love with Sonia and desiring to build a life with her after he finishes his prison sentence.
Criticism
I had high hopes for Crime and Punishment. Many people online claim this is one of the greatest novels of all time, that “it will destroy you” psychologically. Perhaps these high expectations are the cause of my general ambivalence towards the book after finishing it. I genuinely don’t understand what the message of this novel is.
Is the point of this novel that it’s psychologically difficult to disobey the moral system you were raised in, due to the internal guilt you feel after doing so? Even a child could tell you that, and they wouldn’t take 500+ pages to do so.
Or, perhaps the point Dostoyevsky wanted to make is that true love or Christian faith is the best way to live, as opposed to detached utilitarianism? If that’s the case, then Dostoyevsky should have ripped out about a hundred pages from the middle of the book that drone on and on about how guilty Raskolnikov feels, and inserted an epilogue describing a fulfilling life about him following Christian morals and loving his wife.
The only reason I can fathom that this book sits near the top of the literary pantheon is due to its thorough psychological descriptions. That aspect of the novel is somewhat interesting, but in my opinion does not make it worthy of its esteemed position.
Comments
Post a Comment